Earlham College is a college that is underestimated as a liberal arts school. The college makes up for it with the amount of community that the college praises. My education here so far is satisfying....it is never to hard or to easy. There is always a push or challenge in whatever class you take.
In terms of my major (HDSR), I really do enjoy the projects and discussions. As well, another potential major I have is PAGS. I'm on the fence for it because it can be biased. I also considered education. There is an MAT program, but education is not a big major here, if that is what you care for.
Earlham is also a great school for those of a science major. The science majors here are intense, especially Biology/Chemistry. Art as well.
Teachers in general are very helpful and are very nice. They really do want to help you, so don't be shy to ask them for assistance. Majority of the time, the door is always open. Again, the sense of community is there.